Relationships of Lead, Mercury and Cadmium Levels with the Timing of Menarche among Korean Girls

Article information

Child Health Nurs Res. 2020;26(1):98-106

Publication date (electronic) : 2020 January 31

doi : https://doi.org/10.4094/chnr.2020.26.1.98

Hye Seon Choi

Assistant Professor, College of Nursing, Woosuk University, Wanju, Korea

Corresponding author Hye Seon Choi https://orcid.org/0000-0003-4834-2723 College of Nursing, Woosuk University, 443 Samnye-ro, Samnye-eup, Wanju 55338, Korea TEL +82-63-290-1628 FAX +82-63-290-1548 E-MAIL hschoi@woosuk.ac.kr

*This study was supported by the research fund of Woosuk University in 2019.

Received 2019 December 14; Revised 2019 December 31; Accepted 2020 January 8.

Abstract

INTRODUCTION

In many countries, rapid industrialization has caused severe and hazardous contamination of soils with heavy metals, as well as particulate matter pollution. Soil contamination with heavy metals and air pollution have emerged as major global concerns, since they are deleterious for the environment and pose potential risks for human health [1,2]. Heavy metals are widely dispersed in the environment; in addition to being present in soil, they can also be found on the ground surface, in groundwater, in the air, and in other settings relevant for human life [3]. Heavy metals enter the body via respiration, skin contact, and oral ingestion of contaminated foods. The most common route of contamination is the consumption of crops grown in soil contaminated with heavy metal [1]. Inhalation is also an important route, as tiny particulate matter in the air-often so small as to be invisible without a microscope-may readily enter the lungs through the respiratory system [2,4].

After entering the body, heavy metals form complexes with other substances within the body; as a result, they are not easily eliminated, and tend to accumulate [5]. Heavy metal accumulation results in a variety of harmful effects, which are especially severe in children and adolescents [6]. Developing bodies are especially vulnerable to heavy metal exposure. Of particular concern, children inhale proportionally more air than adults, and their respiratory system filters hazardous materials less efficiently than that of adults because they engage in mouth breathing more frequently [6]. Moreover, the absorption rate of heavy metals through the digestive system is higher in children than in adults, and children’s cumulative exposure may be higher if the duration of exposure extends to adulthood [6]. Furthermore, puberty-accompanied by the development of secondary sexual characteristics-is an important developmental stage in adolescence. Previous studies have reported both positive and negative relationships between blood lead, mercury, and cadmium concentrations and sexual development [7-11]. Therefore, the issue of heavy metal exposure in children and adolescents requires particular attention.

In recent years, particulate matter in the air has become a matter of grave concern in Korea. In 2015, the media mentioned particulate matter 254,913 times, which spiked 2.7-fold in just 2 years to 676,312 times in 2017 [12]. Particulate matter itself contains pollutants, including heavy metals [4]. Another relevant public health issue in Korea is the rising prevalence of precocious puberty. According to data from the Korean Health Insurance Review Agency [13], in the last 5 years, the number of patients with precocious puberty increased by 42.4% from 72,246 in 2014 to 102,886 in 2018. In particular, there were 11,099 boys with precocious puberty and 91,787 girls in 2018, with 8.27 times more girls than boys [13]. Precocious puberty refers to a phenomenon in which pubertal development occurs abnormally earlier and more quickly compared to other children of the same age [14]. In general, a girl is diagnosed with precocious puberty if she develops secondary sexual characteristics younger than the age of 8 (breast bud development at <8 years old; pubic hair development at <9 years old; menarche at <9~10 years old) [14]. Overall, precocious puberty has become a social issue in Korea, and the high prevalence of precocious puberty in girls has become an even more serious problem.

Until recently, most research on heavy metal elements has focused on the correlations of blood heavy metal concentrations with food ingestion [15] and children’s products [16]. Earlier research related to precocious puberty placed a greater emphasis on the diagnosis and treatment of precocious puberty [14], the characteristics of precocious puberty, and psychosocial issues [17]. Research conducted to explore relationships between precocious puberty and heavy metal exposure in Korea is relatively rare. Additionally, previous studies have reported no significant relationships [18,19] and even opposite findings regarding the relationship between sexual development and heavy metal concentrations [8-11,20], and these discrepancies underscore the necessity of further research. Moreover, fine dust in Korea is affected by yellow dust in China [4]. According to a recent Chinese study, a significantly earlier age at menarche was found in women with high blood cadmium levels [11]. Therefore, it is necessary to explore differences in the timing of menarche in Korean girls according to blood heavy metal concentrations.

Traditionally, the onset of menstruation has been considered the most significant indicator of sexual maturity in girls [21]. Thus, by analyzing data from the Korean National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (KNHANES), which contains representative data on the nutritional status of the entire Korean population [22], we explored differences in the timing of menarche according to blood heavy metal concentrations, considering that age at menarche is a major parameter used to diagnose precocious puberty.

METHODS

RESULTS

1. Participant Demographics and Characteristics

The subjects of this study were all females, with a mean age of 14.4 years. Their economic status was distributed as follows: mid-high, 32.2%; high, 27.4%; mid-low, 25.4%; and low, 15.0%. The vast majority of participants (48.3%) lived in the capital area. Furthermore, 57.3% and 42.7% of participants lived in apartments (flats) and houses, respectively. The mean age at menarche was 12.2 years. The participants’ mean height and body weight were 158.7±0.6 cm and 53.4±0.9 kg, respectively, and their mean BMI was 21.08±0.27 kg/m² (Table 1).

Table 1.

Participants’ Characteristics (N=179)

2. Differences in Age at Menarche by Participants' Characteristics

There were no significant differences in economic status, residential area, housing type, body weight, or BMI among the participants whose age at menarche was 10 years, 11 years, 12 years, 13 years, or ≥14 years, but height showed a significant difference across these groups (F=3.54, p=.008) (Table 2).

Table 2.

Differences in Age at Menarche by Participants’ Characteristics (N=179)

3. Blood Heavy Metal Concentrations

Table 3 shows differences in blood heavy metal concentrations according to participants’ characteristics. There were statistically significant differences in geometric mean values according to residential area (lead: F=3.21, p=.014) and age at menarche (lead: F=7.10, p<.001, mercury: F=3.17, p=.015). However, there were no significant differences in the geometric mean values of blood lead, mercury, and cadmium according to economic status or housing type (Table 3).

Table 3.

Differences in Blood Heavy Metal Concentrations by Participants’ Characteristics (N=179)

In the participants of this study, the geometric mean values of blood lead, mercury, and cadmium concentrations were 1.15±0.04 μg/dL, 1.80±0.08 μg/L, and 0.30±0.03 μg/L, respectively. Mercury poisoning (>5 μg/L) was found in 1.5% of participants (Table 3).

4. Blood Heavy Metal Concentrations According to Age at Menarche

In the participants of this study, significant relationships were found between blood lead and mercury concentrations and age at menarche (p for trend: p<.001 and p=.015, respectively). Higher blood lead and mercury concentrations were associated with a significantly lower age at menarche (Table 4).

Table 4.

Blood Heavy Metal Concentrations According to Age at Menarche

DISCUSSION

The blood heavy metal concentrations observed in this study in Korean girls were higher than those generally reported in children from other major advanced nations. In this study, the geometric mean of blood lead concentrations in girls between 10 and 18 years of age was 1.15 μg/dL, according to our analysis of KNHANES 2013 data. In contrast, in the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (NHANES) in the United States (US) [24], the average lead concentration was 0.57 μg/dL in participants between 6 and 11 years of age (2013~2014), and 0.51 μg/dL among those 12 to 19 years of age (2013~2014). According to the Canadian Health Measures Survey (CHMS) [25], the geometric mean of lead concentrations was 0.71 μg/dL in children 6 to 11 years of age (2012~2013) and 0.64 μg/dL in those 12 to 19 years of age (2012~2013). In this study, the geometric mean of blood mercury concentrations was 1.80 μg/L, which was significantly higher than the concentrations reported in children in the US and Canada, which were 0.33 μg/L (6~11 years, 2011~2012), 0.41 μg/L (12~19 years, 2013~2014) in the NHANES data [24], and 0.28 μg/L (6~11 years, 2009~2011) and 0.27 μg/L (12~19 years, 2009~2011) in the CHMS data [25]. The geometric mean of blood cadmium concentrations was 0.30 μg/L in this study, which was also significantly elevated relative to the levels reported in the US and Canada, which were 0.13 μg/L (12~19 years, 2013~2014) in the NHANES data [24], and 0.10 μg/L (6~11 years, 2009~2011) and 0.17 μg/L (12~19 years, 2009~2011) in the CHMS data [25]. As shown above, Korean girls’ blood heavy metal concentrations were more than twice as high as those of similar-aged children in the North American region. In particular, mercury concentrations were almost five fold higher, and 1.5% of the subjects exceeded the 5 μg/L threshold that indicates poisoning according to the HBM standard [26], suggesting the need for more intensive control of children’s mercury intake.

Mercury thermometers, plastic toys, houses and toys with paint containing heavy metals, and living in a deteriorated environment have been identified as significant factors affecting children’s exposure to heavy metals [6]. In particular, children aged 7~18 in Korea spent 21 hours a day, on average, in indoor spaces such as houses and schools [27]. We can cautiously infer that such a living environment may have contributed to the elevated levels of blood heavy metal concentrations observed in Korean children. Recently, environmental pollution has received attention as a cause of heavy metal exposure. Pollution in the soil and air causes the accumulation of heavy metals in the ecosystem, and humans-as the apex of the food chain-ingest these food sources, leading to accumulations of heavy metals that are not eliminated through feces [1]. In Korea, the most prevalent route of environmental heavy metal exposure is the ingestion of food items produced in a contaminated environment [28]. Therefore, blood heavy metal concentrations in children are affected by the food they eat. For instance, the intake of grains, vegetables, fruits, fish, and shellfish tends to be higher in Korea than in the US, reflecting differences in culinary culture [27]. Therefore, eating habits may be a major factor contributing to the observed differences in blood heavy metal concentrations.

This study revealed that higher blood concentrations of lead and mercury were associated with lower ages at menarche. Exposure to endocrine-disrupting chemicals (EDCs) such as lead, cadmium, mercury, and polychlorinated biphenyls, among others [29], during the developmental stages of the central nervous system and sexual differentiation can alter the course of puberty [5,7]. Some EDCs mimic hormones, essentially tricking our body into thinking that they are hormones, while other EDCs block natural hormones from doing their job [5]. Exposure to lead interferes with various aspects of the hypothalamic-pituitary-gonadal axis, including the disruption of hormonal pathways, estradiol levels in females, luteinizing hormone levels, and follicle-stimulating hormone levels [5,7]. These commonly known environmental toxins act as EDCs in the body to promote early puberty [5,29]. This study showed no significant differences in age at menarche according to the participants’ characteristics. Accordingly, early menarche in Korean girls is not caused by economic status, residential area, housing type, or obesity; however, environmental toxins that disturb sexual development can be considered as playing a causative role.

Prior studies showed a negative correlation between lead exposure and pubertal development in animals [30] and humans [8,9,20]. However, many results seem to contradict the findings of the present study. For instance, higher blood lead concentrations were found to delay the pubertal development of South African girls [20]. It was also reported that African-American girls and Mexican-American girls with higher blood mercury concentrations tended to experience a delayed onset of pubertal development [8], and high blood mercury concentrations were specifically found to be associated with significant delays in the development of pubic hair and menarche [9]. Several previous studies have reported that there were no significant relationships between blood mercury concentrations and pubertal development [18,19], which also did not correspond with the findings of the present study. Furthermore, previous research findings regarding cadmium concentrations and pubertal development are not consistent. A cohort study [10] in the US reported that high levels of urinary cadmium were associated with delayed menarche, but in a more recent study [11], Chinese girls who were exposed to cadmium showed early menarche.

We suggest that the discrepancies between previous research and this study can be explained in terms of differences in the research subjects (race), variation in physical and social environments, and the absolute levels of blood heavy metal concentrations. In the US, a significant difference was found in the correlations between blood heavy metal concentrations and the timing of menarche across Caucasian girls, African-American girls, and Mexican-American girls [8]. In the abovementioned study of Chinese girls, the relationship between the timing of menarche and the degree of heavy metal contamination varied depending on whether girls resided in an environment contaminated by heavy metals. The girls who resided in moderately or severely contaminated environments had a high risk of premature menarche before the age of 13 [11]. However, in our opinion, the most significant reason for the discrepancies between our findings and those of previous studies is the difference in the absolute levels of blood heavy metal concentrations. In studies reporting that higher blood heavy metal concentrations significantly delayed menarche, the concentrations were generally higher than in the subjects of this study, to the point that some were classified as experiencing heavy metal poisoning [8,9].

Children and adolescents are often characterized as vulnerable populations susceptible to the adverse effects of environmental pollution. Therefore, they are usually at the forefront of environmental health policies. In the US and Germany, governments gather national biomonitoring data to track biological indicators regarding children’s and adolescents’ exposure to environmental hazards. Moreover, those governments assess a variety of national environmental health indicators as a basis for designing and promoting scientifically-grounded environmental health policies. However, the Korean government has insufficient means to assess children’s and adolescents’ exposure to environmental hazards through biological samples, despite the existence of nationwide sampling surveys such as the KNHANES and the Korean National Environmental Health Survey (KoNEHS). Those surveys are performed rather sporadically, instead of in a continuous way that would provide reliable monitoring information. Of even greater concern than the possibility that heavy metal exposure may induce premature menarche is the link between heavy metal exposure and elevated risks for various conditions related to female sex hormones [21]. When a child exposed to a contaminated environment grows into adulthood, she may suffer from subfertility or infertility, and she may be at a higher risk of obesity, hypertension, breast cancer, ovarian cancer, and endometrial cancer [5,21]. Hence, the issues that arise from exposure to hazardous materials during growth and development may result in a deteriorated quality of living, productivity, and social burden throughout the lifecycle of an individual.

Thus, extensive and ongoing nationwide surveys are needed to obtain data for assessing exposure to environmental hazards and the subsequent consequences for health; such data would help combat pollution, which is becoming an ever more severe problem, and would help prevent and control precocious puberty in Korean children. Since children are not yet physically mature, they require adults’ protection and care. Because children’s primary caretakers may exert an especially significant effect on their health, nationwide surveys should include both children and their family members, especially parents.

This study is subject to certain limitations due to its retrospective design. Furthermore, the KNHANES data do not contain information on breast or public hair development, which would be helpful for diagnosing precocious puberty in girls. Therefore, this study used only age at menarche as an indicator of precocious puberty. It was also not possible to analyze some other variables related to heavy metals and precocious puberty, such as diet, physical activity, and internal and external environmental factors (psychosocial status, living environment, and maternal age at menarche). Nevertheless, this study is significant in that it analyzed associations between blood heavy metal concentrations in Korean children and age at menarche, which had not been attempted previously, using representative national data, and it revealed that elevated lead and mercury levels increased the risk of precocious puberty.

CONCLUSION

The blood heavy metal concentrations in Korean girls and adolescents aged 10~18 were 2~5 times higher than has been reported in advanced countries. Fortunately, the blood lead and cadmium concentrations did not exceed the CDC recommendations. However, 1.5% of subjects showed blood mercury concentrations that exceeded the levels recommended by the HBM standard, meaning that the risk of health damage exceeded the expected level in sensitive individuals. A major problem found in this study is that Korean girls faced an increasing risk of precocious puberty, as they showed a younger age at menarche in response to higher blood lead and mercury concentrations.

Children and adolescents are still developing, and exposure to harmful substances in this period has an effect on lifetime health. Therefore, a systematic, ongoing monitoring system for heavy metals is needed at the national level. These findings should also spur an additional interest in the environment.

Article information Continued